Asked if Kristen Bell's recent success, bringing back her old 90s character would inspire her to do the same, Sarah responded with a pretty unequivocal no.
After posing for snaps on Twitter on two occasions, first with Seth Green and Michelle Trachenberg, then with David Boreanas, we think this is a little harsh.
We have feelings Sarah.
She told Access Hollywood, "Buffy was [already] a movie. See, I think people forget that. Buffy was a movie first, and I don't know if you guys know this, but it didn't really work!
I see you laughing at me over there, but it kind of didn't work. We spent our whole first year or two apologising for the movie.
So, I think it would be an incredibly different pressure."
We know, devastating.
Not, only that, Buffy - sorry, Sarah Michelle Gellar - went on to add that she was too old to be a Vampire Slayer now.
She added: "Plus, I'm a little old now. I feel like Buffy would have a wooden stake walker. I'm not quite sure how that would work."
Well thanks Sarah, now we feel old as well as sad.
Best Buffy quotes
BUFFY AND ANGEL ARE BACK TOGETHER. WE HAVE QUESTIONS.
TOP 15 POWER WOMEN IN TV HISTORY
MORE TV AND CELEB NEWS