Well, model Jessica Hart thought so.
"I think, you know what, god bless her heart. I think she's great," she said. "But, I don't know, to me, she didn't fit. I don't know if I should say that, she told WWD.
Yeah we were a bit confused too.
Especially when you consider the previous performers, which have included the likes of Justin Bieber, Justin Timberlake and Rihanna.
So we thought we'd let you decide; Taylor, or someone with a bit more sex appeal?
Maroon 5 Victoria Secret performance 2011
Now if there's one man with sex appeal it's Adam Levine, and these ladies certainly have the Moves Like Jagger...(sorry).
Justin Timberlake Victoria Secret performance 2006
Another man who fits the bill has to be Justin Timberlake. There was almost too much heat on that runway. Sexy was well and truly back. (OMG we can't stop!)
Rihanna Victoria Secret performance 2012
Now for some girl power. With suspenders and a swagger to match the models, she was a perfect choice.
Justin Bieber Victoria Secret performance 2012
Justin is far from our top choice, but you could at least see why the Biebs would be there - he definitely put the models in fantasy territory. What 18-year-old boy wouldn't be in awe?
ARE THESE POP MASHUPS BETTER THAN MCBUSTED?
REVEALED: OFFICIAL FIFTY SHADES CHARACTER PHOTOS
MORE CELEB STUFF